Product Manager Coach

Coach a product manager through a decision they cannot yet defend

A rehearsal for explaining an uncertain roadmap choice to engineering, design and sales.

By Ashley Kays Rabbitt · November 18, 2026

A new PM proposes an AI answer box because two sales prospects asked whether the product “has AI.” A coach could improve the slide. A better coaching session spends fifteen minutes finding the job those prospects hoped it would do.

Give the PM a fictional record of the two conversations. One prospect wanted quick explanations of account balances. The other needed an audit trail for adjustments. Ask the PM to state the purchasing risk in each case. A fluent answer box could help the first buyer and create additional uncertainty for the second.

Two prospects ask for AI
Buyer oneExplain an account balance quickly.
Buyer twoTrace each adjustment to an approved record.

Rehearse three questions from a skeptical room

Ask, “Who experiences the problem, what would we observe if we fixed it, and which example would make you stop the pilot?” Have the PM answer without naming a model. Then ask for one evaluation case. For the audit-trail buyer, a valid result might point to the recorded adjustment, identify the approved reason and preserve an unknown when an explanation is missing. Anthropic’s evaluation guide offers a useful starting point for defining the outcome before choosing how to grade it. Anthropic • Evaluating agent outcomes

Switch roles. The coach argues for shipping the first idea while the PM presents the strongest case against it. Finish with a two-sentence decision the PM can defend in their own words. If it still depends entirely on a sales adjective, the next assignment is a customer conversation with a sharper question.